Head-to-head
Checkatrade vs Which? Trusted Traders for tradespeople
Quick verdict
Which? Trusted Traders scores higher overall (3.7 vs 3.5). Choose Checkatrade if you want: established trades who want the most recognised badge plus a steady, planned lead flow. Choose Which? Trusted Traders if you want: trades who win on trust and want the strongest consumer-brand endorsement.
Side by side
| Checkatrade | Which? Trusted Traders | |
|---|---|---|
| Our score | 3.5 | 3.7 |
| Pricing model | Membership + fixed lead plans; pay-per-lead credits | Endorsement membership (no per-lead fees) |
| Headline price | From £30/mo + VAT | £66/mo + £248 assessment (0–3 staff) |
| Contract | 12 months (fixed plans) | Rolling, 3 months' notice |
| How leads are priced | Growth plans: you pick your trade, postcodes and how many leads you want a year, then pay a fixed monthly amount. Exact price isn't listed; it depends on trade, area and lead volume. | No per-lead fees: it's an endorsement and listing, paid monthly or yearly. |
| Cancellation | Fixed plan memberships are for 12 months. Opportunities Board credits have no monthly commitment and expire 6 months after purchase. | Rolling endorsement with no set end date; three months' notice to cancel. |
| Vetting | Up to 12 checks, including ID, address, qualifications, CCJs, company history and financial checks. | Credit report, customer reference checks and an on-site interview with a trading standards professional; DBS check for the person running the business. |
| Trustpilot* | 4.7 (91,343) | 4.6 (447) |
| Best for | Established trades who want the most recognised badge plus a steady, planned lead flow | Trades who win on trust and want the strongest consumer-brand endorsement |
Facts from each platform's own pages, checked 18 Nov 2026. *Trustpilot score (review count), mostly homeowner reviews.
Criterion by criterion
| Checkatrade | Which? Trusted Traders | Edge | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price transparency (25%) | 4/5 | 5/5 | Which? Trusted Traders |
| Contract & flexibility (20%) | 2/5 | 3/5 | Which? Trusted Traders |
| Lead control (20%) | 3/5 | 2/5 | Checkatrade |
| Vetting & trust badge (15%) | 5/5 | 5/5 | Draw |
| Lead protection (10%) | 3/5 | 2/5 | Checkatrade |
| Public reputation (10%) | 5/5 | 5/5 | Draw |
Whichever you pick, the follow-up decides the result
Two firms on the same platform can get very different results from the same leads. Our free audit shows where yours drop out.
What happens in a free lead audit · Sales and growth consultancy